When it comes to treating skin cancer, choosing the right surgical method is crucial for both recovery and long-term outcomes.
One of the most common dilemmas patients face is deciding between Mohs Surgery and traditional excision.
If you’ve recently been diagnosed with basal cell carcinoma, squamous cell carcinoma, or another form of skin cancer, understanding your treatment options can help you make a confident, informed decision. At John Vine, MD, we emphasize patient education and personalized care to ensure the best possible outcomes.
What is Mohs Surgery?
Mohs Surgery is a highly specialized and precise technique used to treat certain types of skin cancer. Named after Dr. Frederic Mohs, who developed the procedure in the 1930s, this method involves removing cancerous tissue layer by layer while examining each layer under a microscope in real-time. This process continues until only cancer-free tissue remains. Because it targets only the cancerous cells and spares as much healthy tissue as possible, Mohs Surgery is known for its high success rate and minimal scarring.
See also: Heart-Healthy Habits for Seniors: What Works?
What is Traditional Excision?
Traditional excision involves surgically cutting out the visible tumor along with a margin of surrounding healthy tissue to ensure that all cancerous cells are removed. The tissue is then sent to a laboratory for analysis, which may take a few days. While this method is effective, it lacks the real-time analysis that Mohs Surgery offers, which can sometimes lead to the need for additional surgeries if not all the cancer was removed initially.
Key Differences Between Mohs Surgery and Traditional Excision
Precision:
Mohs Surgery: Offers microscopic examination of each tissue layer during the procedure, increasing accuracy.
Traditional Excision: Tissue is evaluated post-surgery, which may not catch all cancer cells immediately.
Cure Rates:
Mohs Surgery: Boasts up to a 99% cure rate for primary basal cell carcinomas and squamous cell carcinomas.
Traditional Excision: Typically offers a 90-93% cure rate, which is effective but not as high.
Tissue Preservation:
Mohs Surgery: Removes only cancerous tissue, preserving as much healthy skin as possible.
Traditional Excision: Removes a wider margin, which may result in more noticeable scarring.
Scarring and Cosmetic Outcomes:
Mohs Surgery: Preferred for areas like the face, ears, and hands where aesthetics are a concern.
Traditional Excision: May be used for areas where cosmetic outcomes are less critical.
Time and Convenience:
Mohs Surgery: Typically completed in one day but may take several hours.
Traditional Excision: Quicker surgery, but results take longer due to lab processing.
Which Procedure is Best for You?
The decision between Mohs Surgery and traditional excision depends on several factors, including:
Type and Size of Cancer: Mohs is often recommended for high-risk or recurring skin cancers.
Location: Lesions in cosmetically sensitive areas benefit more from the precision of Mohs.
Previous Treatments: Patients who have had recurrences are ideal candidates for Mohs.
Patient Health and Preferences: Discussing your options with a qualified dermatologist or surgeon can help tailor the treatment to your needs.
Why Mohs Surgery is Often the Preferred Choice
Given its precision, high success rate, and cosmetic advantages, Mohs Surgery is frequently chosen over traditional excision, particularly for skin cancers located on the face, scalp, neck, and hands. It’s also ideal for cancers that have returned after previous treatment.
At John Vine, MD, we specialize in Mohs Surgery and are dedicated to providing state-of-the-art treatment options that align with each patient’s specific needs. Our goal is to deliver not only the highest cure rate but also the best possible cosmetic outcomes.
The Role of Technology in Skin Cancer Treatment
In recent years, advancements in health technology have made skin cancer diagnosis and treatment more efficient and accurate. Platforms like RankRover.io help medical professionals and clinics improve their online presence, making it easier for patients to find trusted specialists in Mohs Surgery and other dermatological treatments. Better visibility translates to more informed patients and quicker access to quality care.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between Mohs Surgery and traditional excision is a decision that should be made with the guidance of an experienced medical professional. While both methods are effective, Mohs Surgery offers superior precision, a higher cure rate, and better cosmetic results—especially important for visible areas of the body. If you’re considering your treatment options, schedule a consultation to determine the best course of action for your specific condition.
When it comes to your health and appearance, choosing the right treatment makes all the difference. And with the expertise available at John Vine, MD, you’re in capable hands every step of the way.
